Harry Maguire’s tenure at Manchester United has been a tumultuous journey filled with both triumphs and challenges. Transferring from Leicester City in 2019 for a record £80 million, he quickly established himself as a key player, starting every Premier League match in his debut season and contributing to 13 clean sheets. His strength, composure, and leadership were crucial in solidifying the defense.
However, as time progressed, Maguire’s standing began to wane. His once-prominent role diminished under Erik ten Hag, who stripped him of the captaincy, indicating a shift in the team’s direction. Last season, Maguire started only 20 Premier League matches, reflecting his reduced importance in the manager’s plans.
Things took a further downturn in December when Maguire suffered an injury after a series of solid performances, sidelining him for six critical games. This absence allowed younger players, like 19-year-old Willy Kambwala, to step in. Kambwala’s Premier League debut showcased his technical skills, particularly his impressive 90% pass completion rate, but he struggled with the physical demands, losing all his duels during the match against West Ham.
In contrast, 21-year-old Will Fish has been making strides during his loan at Hibernian in Scotland. Over the past two years, he has emerged as a reliable center-back, playing in all 25 matches this season and earning accolades for his performances. Former Hibernian manager Lee Johnson praised Fish’s speed, physicality, and technical ability, suggesting he could be an ideal fit for United in the future.
Fish excels in aerial duels, winning 8 out of 9 this season, and has scored five goals in 56 appearances for Hibernian, showcasing his well-rounded defensive skills.
As Maguire’s future at United hangs in the balance, the development of Fish and Kambwala hints that the club may have potential successors ready to step in. Fish, in particular, has shown significant promise and could be prepared to join the first team after his loan. His maturity and physical attributes make him a strong candidate to eventually replace Maguire.
While Maguire’s aerial prowess and experience are invaluable, the emergence of Fish and Kambwala suggests that United is well-positioned for a new generation of defenders. The upcoming months will be critical in determining whether Maguire can reclaim his role or if the future will belong to these young talents.
