Why Barcelona Should Avoid Re-Signing Neymar in 2025
Speculation is growing about Neymar’s potential return to Barcelona in the summer of 2025. With Joan Laporta reportedly aiming for a marquee signing to mark the club’s return to the renovated Spotify Camp Nou, Neymar’s name has been mentioned as a possible option. While Erling Haaland remains the priority, Neymar is seen as an alternative due to his contract at Al-Hilal nearing its end. However, bringing him back may not be in Barcelona’s best interest. Here’s why:
1. Persistent Injury Concerns
Neymar has struggled with injuries throughout his career, limiting his playing time significantly. Since joining Al-Hilal in 2023, he has made just five appearances due to an ACL injury. His tenure at PSG was also plagued by frequent injuries, often sidelining him for long periods.
For instance, he missed 33 games in the 2018/19 season and was out for 130 days due to ankle surgery in 2022/23. Given Barcelona’s need for stability, signing an injury-prone player would be a major risk.
2. No Clear Role in the Squad
Barcelona’s current squad already has strong options on the left wing, Neymar’s preferred position. Ferran Torres and Raphinha are key contributors, and with Nico Williams expected to join in 2025, adding Neymar would only create unnecessary competition and block the development of younger players.
3. Financial Burden
One of the biggest hurdles is Neymar’s massive salary. At Al-Hilal, he earns around €100 million per year—far beyond what Barcelona can afford, given their ongoing financial struggles. Even with a pay cut, his wages would still be a significant strain on the club’s budget.
4. Dressing Room Disruption
Neymar’s departure from Barcelona in 2017 was controversial, and his return could stir unnecessary tension within the squad. Maintaining harmony in the dressing room should be a priority for the club.
5. Declining Performance
At 33 years old in 2025, Neymar may no longer be the explosive player he once was. His recent form has been inconsistent, raising doubts about whether he can still perform at the highest level.
6. Commitment & Focus Issues
Throughout his career, Neymar’s discipline and off-field lifestyle have been questioned. Barcelona needs players fully dedicated to their long-term project, and there are concerns about whether Neymar would fit that vision.
7. Better Alternatives Available
Instead of investing in an aging star, Barcelona should focus on signing younger, more promising talents who can serve the club for years to come.
Conclusion
Although Neymar’s return may excite some fans, it would be an unwise move for Barcelona. His injury history, lack of a defined role, high wages, and potential dressing room issues make him a poor fit for a club aiming to rebuild and ensure financial stability. Instead of revisiting the past, Barcelona should prioritize a future-oriented squad with reliable young talent.
