Despite Real Madrid’s defeat to Valencia, the main talking point wasn’t the final score but a heated VAR controversy that’s reignited debate over video refereeing in Spain. The focus? A contentious penalty awarded to Kylian Mbappé following contact from Valencia defender César Tárrega.
What Happened?
In the second half, Mbappé went to ground inside the box after a challenge from Tárrega. Referee Cuadra Fernández promptly pointed to the spot. However, VAR official Figueroa Vázquez intervened, asking Fernández to review the incident.
A leaked audio clip from the VAR room has sparked backlash:
“I recommend you come to see the play so that it won’t be a penalty,” Vázquez said.
This wording—seeming to steer the decision rather than encourage objective review—has angered fans and reignited concerns about the impartiality of VAR communication.
Referee Holds His Ground
Despite the VAR advice, Cuadra Fernández stuck to his original decision after reviewing the footage:
“There’s a touch that unbalances Kylian while contesting the ball. That’s what brings him down… I stand by the penalty call.”
The penalty was upheld—but the drama didn’t stop there.
Vinícius Jr. Misses – and Feels the Heat
Vinícius Jr. took the penalty and missed, drawing loud boos from the home crowd. With his form under increasing scrutiny in 2025, the miss only added to the pressure, straining his relationship with Real Madrid fans—some going so far as to suggest a growing disconnect between the player and the Bernabéu faithful.
Broader Concerns Emerge
This incident has triggered new discussions across Spanish football:
- Should VAR simply show replays rather than guide decisions?
- Was Cuadra Fernández justified in dismissing the VAR’s advice?
- Who should take Real Madrid’s penalties moving forward?
Beyond this one moment, the controversy reflects deeper issues around transparency, referee independence, and the proper role of VAR. And with Real Madrid still in contention for trophies, such tensions could have significant implications as the season reaches its climax.
