Liverpool vs Manchester United Referee Analysis: Three Major Errors by Michael Oliver
Referee Michael Oliver faced strong criticism after a series of controversial decisions influenced the outcome of Liverpool’s clash with Manchester United at Anfield.
United took the lead within the opening minute through Bryan Mbeumo, marking their first back-to-back victories under Ruben Amorim. Cody Gakpo equalized in the second half, but Harry Maguire’s late header sealed a crucial win for the visitors — moving them within two points of Liverpool in the Premier League table and easing pressure on Amorim.
However, Oliver’s officiating drew scrutiny for three key errors that affected the game’s rhythm and fairness.
1. Failure to Stop Play for Mac Allister’s Head Injury
Before Mbeumo’s opener, the United forward collided with Alexis Mac Allister in midfield. The Liverpool midfielder fell to the ground clutching his head, but play continued as Oliver claimed he hadn’t seen the incident.
According to the rules, play must be stopped immediately for potential head injuries. The assistant referee and fourth official also failed to alert Oliver, allowing United’s attack to continue — culminating in the opening goal.
2. Controversial Non-Penalty Decision Against Diallo
In the first half, Amad Diallo appeared to handle the ball inside the penalty area when blocking a cross from Gakpo. While the ball clearly struck his arm, VAR deemed the position “natural,” and no on-field review was requested.
Replays suggested, however, that Diallo had turned his body to make contact with the cross — an action that could have warranted a penalty had Oliver taken another look.
3. Harsh Yellow Card for Diallo’s Sliding Challenge
Diallo was later booked for a strong but seemingly fair sliding tackle on Gakpo. Though he cleanly won the ball, his follow-through caught the Liverpool forward’s foot — leaving Oliver to brandish the first yellow card of the game.
It was Diallo’s third foul, and Oliver appeared to apply a cumulative decision rather than judge the tackle on its own merits. The booking ultimately forced Amorim to substitute the wing-back with 30 minutes remaining.
Despite the controversy, Diallo’s overall performance reflected his growing importance under Amorim, following his new contract signed last year. Still, Oliver’s officiating once again raised questions about consistency and communication among Premier League referees
