Chris Sutton’s critique of Virgil van Dijk has reignited the debate over whether the Dutch defender is still at the peak of his powers. While it’s true that his pre-injury form set an almost impossible standard—dominating attackers, exuding calm leadership, and elevating Liverpool to new heights—his post-injury performances have still been of a high caliber, even if not quite as imperious.
Van Dijk remains Liverpool’s defensive leader and is crucial to their title charge this season. His positioning, aerial dominance, and composure on the ball are still elite, even if some believe he’s lost half a step since that devastating injury in 2020. The fact that he’s still being compared to the best in the league shows his enduring quality.
Do you think Van Dijk is still among the top defenders in the Premier League, or has time and injury taken a toll?
