“THIS IS ABSOLUTELY PATHETIC FROM A LEGEND!” – FORMER FIFA REFEREE SLAMS JAMIE CARRAGHER
Premier League punditry drama has escalated as former FIFA referee Keith Hackett tore into Liverpool legend Jamie Carragher following his fiery reaction to a referee’s decision during a recent clash.
Carragher, known for his passionate commentary on Sky Sports, branded the decision a “disgrace” live on air, prompting Hackett—former head of PGMOL—to fire back:
“This is pathetic coming from a man seen as a legend of the sport. I know refereeing in the EPL has been questionable, but the referee made the right call this time. I think Jamie Carragher should get a five-match ban for such behaviour.”
The attack has reignited debate over whether pundits should face accountability for on-air outbursts, particularly when millions are watching. Carragher’s aggressive response overshadowed the match and raised concerns about whether high-profile figures are inflaming the ongoing discourse around officiating standards.
Fan reactions are split: Liverpool supporters largely defend Carragher, while neutrals echo Hackett’s call for restraint. On social media, some labeled Hackett’s criticism “over the top,” while others agreed that Carragher’s behaviour was “embarrassing” for someone of his stature.
Refereeing in England has long been under scrutiny due to VAR controversies and inconsistent calls. Hackett insists that criticism should not cross into “disrespectful behaviour that damages the integrity of the sport,” emphasizing that pundits have a responsibility to show restraint—even in moments of frustration.
While Carragher is unlikely to face a formal ban, Hackett’s comments have intensified the debate over pundit conduct, referees’ protection, and the boundaries of commentary in the Premier League. The clash between referees, pundits, and fans shows no signs of slowing down.
